Health.wikia (http://www.health.wikia.com/index.php?title=Main_Page) is an American health encyclopedia that looked to be really promising, it looked great and it’s contents page was very healthy. Sadly though I was soon disappointed, I followed links for several topics and alas there was no content just an invitation to contribute. I guess that is the trouble with Wiki’s, they rely on audience participation!!!
After searching further I discovered Wiki Mental Health (http://www.wikimentalhealth.co.uk/Main_Page) this wiki covers the topic of law and mental health. It really demonstrates everything you would expect from a wiki, there are regular contributions and it is up-to-date. This wiki does also have an overall editor who created the site who regularly contributes and joins in discussions. This gives a sense of ownership, that someone cares about the site and that it hasn't just been set up and abandoned.
Law is constantly being revised so makes a great topic for taking advantage of a wiki's many features, revisions are instant, and the ability for multiple contributions invites a wealth of knowledge and experiences to be shared.
Although no oil painting the layout and navigation of this site has been well thought about. It is very easy to get around and see what content is available at a quick glance. The wiki is divided up into case law, legislation and general information. The legislation covers the Mental Health Act, crime and human rights, and the wiki claims to have the only free & fully-amended source of the Mental Health Act 1983 and related legislation. The case law section includes summaries of cases, and the general information includes explanations of terminology and practical guidance for lawyers.
Wednesday, 7 November 2007
Blogging Assignment No.3
I chose to search for information on Dementia using social book marking sites. Del.icio.us I noticed returned a lot of non-health related sites, and basically a lot of rubbish. It included numerous videos from U-Tube, comic books and dubious looking news sites. Looking at the urls there were no NHS, gov or edu sites making the reliability of the sites questionable. It was also noted that there were a lot of .coms, mostly biased commercial sites. The only sites that look remotely medical related were the sponsored links.
Next I tried the same search but on www.digg.com this site looked nicer than del.icio.us and was easier to use. The results that were returned were also much better; there were links to news articles and recent developments. This site had no sponsored links all the content comes from its members, this would surely limit any bias from commercial sites. Even thought the bookmarks had fewer hits, indicating a smaller membership than del.icio.us the information was more relevant and useful.
Part 2
It seems that it is much harder to find credible information using social book marking sites primarily because they are put together and edited by the general public, therefore the needs and expectations are different for each person, information that one person finds interesting could be totally mind numbing to the next. That said the concept of social book marking sites remains a clever one and potentially a very useful one. Some of the problems encountered during my exploration would probably not occur between like minded groups. Therefore social book marking in a library setting could be very useful, especially in the dynamic world of medicine where information is constantly updating.
Library resources posted to a social book marking site suddenly can become personally adapted by a particular group of users. Information that was once static can become interactive and fluid. Popular entries can be kept current and anything old or unfavourable can be removed. Social book marking certainly has yet to develop a place in libraries but when it does I am sure that it will prove very useful.
Next I tried the same search but on www.digg.com this site looked nicer than del.icio.us and was easier to use. The results that were returned were also much better; there were links to news articles and recent developments. This site had no sponsored links all the content comes from its members, this would surely limit any bias from commercial sites. Even thought the bookmarks had fewer hits, indicating a smaller membership than del.icio.us the information was more relevant and useful.
Part 2
It seems that it is much harder to find credible information using social book marking sites primarily because they are put together and edited by the general public, therefore the needs and expectations are different for each person, information that one person finds interesting could be totally mind numbing to the next. That said the concept of social book marking sites remains a clever one and potentially a very useful one. Some of the problems encountered during my exploration would probably not occur between like minded groups. Therefore social book marking in a library setting could be very useful, especially in the dynamic world of medicine where information is constantly updating.
Library resources posted to a social book marking site suddenly can become personally adapted by a particular group of users. Information that was once static can become interactive and fluid. Popular entries can be kept current and anything old or unfavourable can be removed. Social book marking certainly has yet to develop a place in libraries but when it does I am sure that it will prove very useful.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)